How to Choose the Best Adoption Agency
Choosing the right adoption agency isn’t just a box to check — it’s a deeply personal decision that will shape one of the most important journeys of your life. From the very first conversation to the moment you welcome your child home, your agency should be a source of compassion, clarity, and confidence.
This guide was created with you in mind — whether you’re just beginning to explore adoption or narrowing down your options. We’re here to walk with you, helping you understand what to look for in a trusted partner and what questions to ask so you can move forward feeling truly supported.
What Makes an Adoption Agency Worth Trusting
No two adoption agencies are the same, and the one you choose should meet both your practical needs and your emotional expectations. Below, you’ll find a simple, approachable way to evaluate your options and find the agency that’s right for you.
1. Experience That Feels Reassuring
When you're choosing someone to guide you through adoption, experience makes all the difference. Agencies that have supported hundreds or even thousands of families tend to understand the process inside and out. They’ve walked with people through joyful beginnings and tough moments alike, and that depth of experience becomes part of the support they offer you.
It’s also reassuring when team members have personal connections to adoption — whether they’re adoptive parents, birth parents, or adoptees themselves. Their empathy adds a level of care that can't be taught.
- Why It Matters: A seasoned agency can help you feel safe, informed, and cared for from start to finish.
- What to Ask: How many adoptions have you completed? Do any of your team members have a personal adoption story?
2. Licensing That Protects Your Future
Working with a licensed agency means you’re choosing a professional team that’s legally allowed to operate and is held to high ethical standards. Ideally, your agency should be licensed not just in your state, but also in any state where they might work with birth families.
This matters because licensing ensures that every part of your journey is being handled with integrity, oversight, and accountability.
- Why It Matters: Licensure offers peace of mind and helps protect your time, finances, and emotional well-being.
- What to Ask: Are you licensed in my state — and in the states where birth parents may live? What does that license cover?
3. Genuine Support for Every Person Involved
A good agency supports more than just paperwork. It supports people — all of them. That means offering adoption services you’ll need, emotional counseling, legal education, and just someone to talk to when things feel uncertain. The right agency is with you every step of the way. And they’ll also be there for birth parents, offering the guidance and respect they deserve.
- Why It Matters: Adoption is a life-changing experience for everyone involved. Everyone deserves care and kindness throughout the process.
- What to Ask: What support do you offer birth parents? Will we have a dedicated specialist guiding us throughout?
4. Clarity Around Costs and Financial Peace of Mind
Let’s be honest — adoption is a significant financial commitment. That’s why you need an agency that’s completely transparent about costs and committed to protecting your investment.
Ask for a clear, detailed breakdown of common adoption fees, and be sure to understand what happens if a placement doesn’t go through. Look for agencies that offer fixed-fee programs or financial protection policies — it shows they’re not just looking out for your wallet, but for your heart, too.
- Why It Matters: Knowing your costs — and your protections — upfront helps reduce stress and allows you to plan confidently.
- What to Ask: What’s included in your fee? What happens if a match falls through?
5. Honest, Ongoing Help with Open Adoption
More families today are exploring open adoption — and it can be a beautiful, meaningful choice. But it also requires guidance, clear boundaries, and emotional support.
The right agency will help you explore different levels of openness and walk you through what it can look like in real life. They’ll also provide the tools and support to help those relationships grow in a healthy, respectful way.
- Why It Matters: Open adoption can offer connection and peace — when it’s handled with care and intention.
- What to Ask: What kind of education and support do you offer for open adoption?
A Simple 3-Step Path to Choosing the Right Agency
Whether you’re gathering information, considering your emotional readiness, or just not quite sure if now is the time — you’re not alone. The right agency will support you, even before you make a decision. Here's a simple path forward to evaluate any agency. by the end of these simple steps, you'll know if you've found a trusted partner.
Step 1: Explore and Compare
Start by looking into several agencies, especially those who are licensed in Michigan and have experience working with families in your area. Visit their websites, read their stories, and review testimonials from other parents.
Look for signs of transparency, compassion, and professionalism. A good agency will make it easy for you to understand what they do and how they can support you.
Compare Adoption Professionals
Step 2: Ask Honest, Important Questions
Reach out to a few agencies and schedule time to talk — over the phone, by video, or even in person if you’re nearby. Ask about their process, support, fees, average cost of adoption, wait times, and anything else that matters to you.
Notice not just what they say, but how they say it. Do they take time to listen? Do they seem interested in your story? Your comfort with them matters.
Step 3: Choose the Agency That Feels Right
When you find the agency that checks the boxes and feels like a good fit, you’ll know. You should feel supported, respected, and ready to move forward.
At that point, your journey officially begins — with paperwork, support, and a team you trust to guide you along the way.
Why So Many Families Choose Us
At American Adoptions, we’ve helped more than 13,000 families across the country grow through adoption. And we do it with one of the shortest average wait times in the nation — just 12 months.
But more than the numbers, we’re proud of how we treat families. Our team includes adoptive parents, birth parents, and adoptees. We understand this journey in a way that only lived experience can teach. We’re here for you — not just as professionals, but as people who truly care.
What Makes Us Different
- Licensed across the U.S. — including in Michigan
- Honest timelines and financial protections
- Personalized support from a team with real adoption experience
- Full-service care from start to finish
You Deserve a Caring, Clear Adoption Journey
This journey is deeply personal — and it’s okay to have questions, hopes, fears, and dreams. The right agency doesn’t just guide you through the steps. It walks beside you, ready to answer your questions and celebrate your milestones.
We hope this guide has helped you feel more empowered and informed. If you're ready to take the next step, we’re here and ready to walk it with you.
Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.